AG’s Office reaches plea deal in 2014 Clearlake murder case
- Elizabeth Larson
- Posted On
LAKEPORT, Calif. – The California Attorney General’s Office has reached a settlement in the 2014 murder of a man who investigators believe was killed in relation to illegal marijuana growing in Clearlake.
Gary Joseph Williams, 34, of Clearlake pleaded last month to voluntary manslaughter with a gun in the death of Guillermo Figueroa, with a number of other counts dismissed, according to his attorney, Patrick Pekin of Fort Bragg.
The Lake County Superior Court Clerk’s Office confirmed that Williams is set to be sentenced at 1:30 p.m. May 6 in Department 3 before Judge David Markham.
The California Attorney General’s Office began handling the case’s prosecution early on because of a conflict of interest for then-District Attorney Don Anderson.
Specifically, his daughter, Robyn Anderson, her husband Michael Campbell and her daughter, Courtney Crusse, were all named as potential witnesses in court documents. Robyn Anderson was expected to testify at one point and Crusse, who was given immunity, also was to have testified but refused, according to Pekin.
“I had to recuse myself because my granddaughter was a witness,” and a “pretty crucial witness” at that, Anderson – who left office at the end of 2018 – told Lake County News.
Jury selection and motion hearings had been under way in mid-March, when Williams’ trial was set to start. But just days before the trial was to have begun on March 20, Williams and the Attorney General’s Office reached the settlement.
Lake County News made a total of five requests – three by phone, two by email – to the Attorney General’s Office seeking comment on the case settlement, but the agency did not respond.
Pekin said it’s a really good outcome for Williams in a case that originally was considered for the death penalty because it was prosecuted as a murder during the course of a robbery, which is one of the special circumstances that qualifies as a capital offense.
The death penalty was taken off the table by the Attorney General’s Office not long after Pekin came on as Williams’ counsel. At that point, had Williams been tried and convicted, he could have faced life without the possibility of parole.
Pekin said the ultimate offer was voluntary manslaughter with a gun, with a 16-year sentence. Williams has been in custody since Nov. 26, 2014 – he already had been in jail for the theft of a trailer when he was arrested in the Figueroa case in May 2015 – so that four years will count toward his time served.
“The bottom line is, he would be released in about nine years or so,” said Pekin.
That was a much better outcome, said Pekin, than the possibility of losing at trial and having his client face a life sentence.
A missing man and discovered remains
In late October 2014, local law enforcement began investigating Figueroa’s disappearance.
The 36-year-old husband and father of three was reported missing to the Clearlake Police Department by his wife on Oct. 27 after he failed to return home to Hidden Valley Lake from visiting a friend in Clearlake. He had last texted his wife the night before.
The Clearlake Police Department pinged Figueroa’s phone to an area in Clearlake and later found a vehicle registered to him on Burns Valley Road.
Then, on Nov. 28, 2014, Clearlake Police responded to a report from a man who lived in the 2700 block of Oleander Street. The man discovered a human skull in his yard that he believed his dog may have found and brought there.
Teams of detectives, sheriff's deputies, K-Corps members and out-of-county law enforcement personnel combed the isolated, heavily wooded part of the city where the skull was found and, the day after the skull’s discovery, a canine from the Contra Costa County-based California Rescue Dog Association found partial human remains about 100 yards north of the residence where the skull had been located.
An autopsy and DNA results matched the skull and remains as belonging to Figueroa in December 2014.
A complicated case
Pekin said a dispute over marijuana cultivation and collection of funds appeared to be a potential cause in the murder.
Don Anderson said his daughter and son-in-law “knew Williams and there was some marijuana issues going on between them,” adding he didn’t know the extent of it.
When Figueroa’s wife went to the Clearlake Police Department in October 2014 to report his disappearance, she was accompanied by a man who had been with Figueroa at a party the day before. The two men then left and went to the Clearlake Safeway and the man watched Figueroa get into a vehicle with a woman. At the time, Figueroa was reported to have $5,000 in cash on him, but he wouldn’t tell his wife what it was for, according to court documents.
The investigation revealed that Figueroa owned a grow house in Clearlake and was involved in the illegal marijuana growing trade.
Pekin said Figueroa also had been growing marijuana for Campbell.
The investigative trail led to Campbell, who is recounted in court documents as admitting to authorities that Figueroa had been growing marijuana on his property in Clearlake Park. Campbell and his wife and Crusse said people had been looking for Figueroa in connection to the marijuana and money he was said to have owned them.
Other witnesses said they saw Crusse drive Figueroa away from the Clearlake Safeway in her green Mercedes, and that Crusse, who spoke Spanish, often interpreted for Figueroa. There also were details about armed confrontations between two groups over marijuana Figueroa was growing.
At one point in the investigation, Robyn Anderson admitted not being truthful with people – as her daughter also had done – and said her husband had taken Figueroa’s marijuana and had someone transplant it elsewhere.
“Robyn Anderson told Detective Riley that her father, District Attorney Don Anderson, had called her about the case and asked Robyn to go on a drive with him. During the drive, Don questioned Robyn extensively about the case,” the documents said.
As far as his discussion with his daughter, Don Anderson said, “I was not giving her legal advice because she had an attorney.”
He said he also was present at the meetings between his granddaughter and her Fifth Amendment attorney, Andrea Sullivan, adding he gave Crusse “grandfatherly advice.”
Police received information that Williams and his girlfriend, Crystal Pearls, had stolen Figueroa’s marijuana. They then searched Williams’ mother’s home, and found her boyfriend – a convicted felon – in possession of ammunition. Wanting to avoid jail, he offered authorities information – that Williams had admitted to him that he shot “the Mexican” in the face with a .22 revolver and that the “interpreting girl” – Crusse – saw it.
Court documents also state that Williams’ brother told authorities – after he was granted immunity – that Williams admitted to “killing a Mexican.”
Williams was arrested on Nov. 26, 2014, during a sweep of his mother’s home, on charges relating to a trailer theft.
Meanwhile, the investigation continued. Figueroa’s remains were sent to Dr. Allison Galloway at the University of California, Santa Cruz, in January 2015.
Galloway completed her examination of the remains in three weeks, concluding that Figueroa had been shot once or twice in the head. One of the wounds, in the forehead, was determined to be either a .22 or .32 caliber hole.
A second injury on the right maxillary bone – found in the upper jaw – could have been from a bullet strike, blunt force trauma or animal scavenging. No weapon or slug was recovered.
“He was certainly killed by gunshot,” said Pekin, but added that Galloway couldn’t tell with any degree of certainty how long Figueroa had been dead.
In March 2015, a search warrant was executed on Crusse’s Mercedes, which case documents said was the first time it was inventoried or subjected to any forensic treatment. Investigators found the carpet had been replaced and washed, and the tires rotated.
In May 2015, once more evidence had been gathered and corroborated, Williams was arrested for the murder.
The following month, Crusse, driving a tan Dodge Colt with two male passengers, was stopped by a Clearlake Police officer. A functional Mossberg .22 rifle with a cut short barrel and pistol grip was discovered. “Crusse was evasive as to how long the gun had been in her car and claimed it belonged to her great grandfather,” according to trial briefs.
“We hadn’t gotten far enough to litigating that,” Pekin said of the rifle, which could have potentially been brought up at trial.
Extensive trial preparation
Pekin said he was “pretty eager” to take the case to trial.
He said Judge Markham scrutinized every piece of evidence, the amount of which was enormous. He said there were estimated to be 50 witnesses, plus DNA and GPS evidence.
The case, Pekin said, had “all the bells and whistles.”
He added, “It had so many forensic aspects to it that are really interesting to work with.”
Pekin said Robyn Anderson and Courtney Crusse were going to be called to the stand.
Crusse was a material witness. “She was close to the case, close enough to be granted immunity,” said Pekin, adding that Crusse had refused to testify.
Don Anderson confirmed that the Attorney General’s Office offered his granddaughter immunity, that she was subpoenaed and was going to show up to the trial. However, he said he couldn’t say if she would have testified.
Andrea Sullivan, the administrator of Lake Indigent Defense, the county’s indigent defense contractor, said she was appointed as Fifth Amendment counsel for Crusse after other available attorneys were disqualified for conflicts.
Sullivan said she couldn’t comment on the course of action Crusse chose to take regarding testifying, but added that Crusse was “one of many” people offered immunity in the case.
Pekin said it was “certainly a possibility” that Don Anderson himself could have been called as a witness, but Anderson told Lake County News that he had not gotten any subpoena or notice to testify.
Jury selection was extensive. Hundreds of potential jurors were interviewed in a two-phase process. Pekin said the trial had been expected to last for about two months, and those individuals who said they could serve for the duration had to fill out a 23-page questionnaire.
Pekin said the case was “really triable,” which he believes is reflected in the offer the Attorney General’s Office made. He said you’re never going to see a 16-year offer in a case that started out as a homicide with a gun.
“I think the court did a really good job,” Pekin said, offering praise for Judge Markham and Deputy Attorney General Peter Flores Jr.
Lake County Probation will do a sentencing report, as is standard. Pekin said it should be fairly straightforward and noncontroversial.
“I’m really grateful that I had the opportunity to work on it at all,” Pekin said of the case.
Email Elizabeth Larson at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.. Follow her on Twitter, @ERLarson, or Lake County News, @LakeCoNews.